The Supreme Court last week limited the Environmental Protection Agency’s ability to regulate greenhouse gas emissions to fight climate change — and that may leave eco-conscious investors wondering what they can do.
Some investment managers offer funds that promote values like environmental preservation and social justice. These funds have become increasingly popular in recent years.
Trying to pick a so-called environmental, social and governance fund — especially one that aligns well with your interests — can seem challenging at first, however.
More on Personal Finance
These 5 metros are home to the most million-dollar houses
You can now take steps to prepare yourself for a recession
These are the steps to take before you start paying student loans again
Fabian Willskytt is associate director of public markets for Align Impact, a financial advisory company that specializes in values-based investments.
Investors who want to make a difference on climate change can follow a few simple steps to get started and to invest with confidence.
A coal-burning power plant.
E+ | E+ | Getty Images
Thursday’s Supreme Court ruling of 6-3 revoked some authority for the EPA to control carbon emissions from U.S. energy plants.
Chief Justice John Roberts, along with five other conservative judges, stated that Congress, and not the EPA has the power to establish a broad system for cap-and-trade regulations to limit the emissions from existing power stations to support the country’s transition from coal to clean energy. (A cap and trade system is one way to reduce emissions.
Fosil fuel-fired power stations are second in the United States for carbon pollution, after transportation.
On February 4, 2020, U.S. Supreme Court Chief Judge John Roberts and Supreme Court justice Elena Kagan met in Washington.
Mario Tama | Getty Images News | Getty Images
Roberts wrote that “Capping carbon dioxide emissions to a level that will require a nationwide switch away from the use coal to generate electricity may be an opportune’solution for the crisis of today’.” It is unlikely that Congress gave EPA authority to create such a regulatory scheme on its own.
Although the decision leaves the EPA with the option to regulate emissions more broadly than before, many see it a major setback in the Biden administration’s plan to combat climate change. Nevertheless, Democrats have blocked climate legislation from Congress.
“Today the Court strips Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),” Justice Elena Kagan wrote in her dissent. She was joined by two other liberal members.
Getty Images| Photographer’s Choice | Getty Images
Funds that allocate investor money according to ESG issues held $357 billion at the end of 2021 — more than four times the total three years earlier, according to Morningstar, which tracks data on mutual and exchange-traded funds.
Morningstar reports that investors invested $69.2 billion in ESG funds last year, a record according to Morningstar.
There are many types of these funds. One might want to promote gender equality or racial equity, invest in green energy technology, or avoid fossil fuel or tobacco companies, for instance.
According to Cerulli Associates survey results, women and younger investors (under 40), are more likely than men to be interested ESG investment. According to the Financial Planning Association, 34% of financial advisors used ESG fund with clients in 2021, compared to 32% in 2020.
There are now more than 550 ESG mutual and exchange-traded funds available to U.S. investors — more than double what was available five years ago, according to Morningstar.
“An individual investor has much more [ESG options]Michael Young, manager of education at the Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment, said that they can now build a portfolio in ways that are different from 10 years ago. “Almost every [asset]Every category I can think about has a fund option, so we have come a long distance.”
But fund managers may use varying degrees of rigor when investing your money — meaning that environment-focused fund you bought may not necessarily be as “green” as you might think.
Here’s a good example: Fund managers may “integrate ESG value when selecting where to invest their money,” but this strategy may only play a supporting role and not a central one. Other managers, on the other hand, have an explicit ESG mandate which acts as the linchpin for their investment decisions.
Investors may not know the difference.
In May, the Securities and Exchange Commission proposed rules that would improve transparency and make it easier for investors to choose the ESG fund that most aligns with their values. The rules would also prohibit “greenwashing”, which is when money managers mislead investors regarding ESG fund holdings.
This may leave you wondering: How do I start? How can I make sure my investments are aligned with my values and beliefs?
ESG experts suggest that investors can take a few easy steps to get started.
According to Willskytt, Align Impact, one way is to start by looking at the asset manager. This serves to be a good “shorthand” for investors.
Some firms are focused on ESG and have a long history of investing this way — both of which are encouraging signs for people serious about values-based investing, he said.
Investors can gauge a firm’s commitment to sustainability by visiting its website. He also mentioned that ESG is a key focus. Investors can then select from the available funds.
“It’s a red alert if you can find the minimum of [website]Jon Hale, director for sustainability research in the Americas at Sustainalytics (owned by Morningstar), said that information is important. It suggests that the commitment may not be as high as it is with other funds.
Here are some examples of ESG-focused companies Calvert Research and Management Impax Asset Management, Willskytt said. NuveenTIAA also owns TIAA’s TIA Investment Fund. He added that TIAA has a long track record in ESG investing.
Morningstar ratedCalvert and Pax were joined by four others (Australian Ethics). Parnassus InvestmentsAccording to an article, Stewart Investors, Robeco and Robeco were the category’s top asset-management executives. ESG Commitment Level2020 assessment (But, not all cater for U.S. individual investors. Six additional companies, including Nuveen/TIAA were ranked a tier lower in the “advanced ESG” category.
Willskytt stated, “If you have confidence that the manager will do a good job, the funds will be stronger from an ESG perspective.” “Then it’s all about finding the flavors which work for you.”
However, there is one drawback. Investors may not find an ESG fund that matches their niche, despite ESG fund expansion. Experts say there are many ESG funds that target climate issues and others that cover a wide range of value-based filters. However, it can be difficult to find a fund that is gun-free.
Morningstar reports that 70% of sustainable funds are actively managed. You may pay a higher annual fee if they are managed more than other funds in your portfolio, depending on your current holdings.
Investors who are interested in learning more about ESG before making the plunge can download a free ESG guide. courseThe Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment has the basics.
DigitalVision | DigitalVision | Getty Images
Investors can also start by searching through a few databases that provide free access to mutual funds and ETFs.
Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment has one databaseThis allows investors to sort ESG funds by asset class (stock or bond, and balanced funds), issue type, and investment minimum.
This list isn’t exhaustive, though — it includes funds from the forum’s member firms. Young stated that being a member of the forum may provide a reliable screening for asset managers’ ESG rigor.
As You SowAnother organization that can assist investors in finding funds that are free of fossil fuels, gender-equal and gun-free, prison-free or weapons-free, is the Funding Source. It maintains rankings of the top fundsBy category
Investors can also use As You Sow’s website for a quick assessment of how their investments are aligned with their values. You can enter the ticker symbol of a fund to generate a score for it according to different value categories.
Other firms assign ESG ratings to specific funds. Morningstar, for instance, assigns a set number of “globes” (5″ being the best score), so investors can assess the fund’s ESG scope. Morningstar offers the following: ESG ScreenerInvestors can also filter for funds using certain parameters.
One caveat: The ESG intent of an asset manager is not necessarily indicated by the globe system or other third-party ratings. A fund could have stellar ESG ratings simply by chance, and not because of a manager’s focus.
Investors can also use fund databases for ESG investments. After identifying potential ESG investments, they can then research the asset management firm to determine how committed they are to ESG.
Working with a financial advisor who is well-versed on ESG may be the best way for investors who are not as DIY-oriented to make sure that their investments match your values and align with your overall portfolio. For example, advisors may have more sophisticated screening tools than retail investors.